
By Elliot Silver, Criminal Defense Attorney, Silver Law Firm · Updated November 2026
Short answer: In most California misdemeanor cases, an Alameda County judge can offer diversion under Penal Code section 1001.95, even if the prosecutor objects. Sex offenses that require registration, domestic violence, stalking, and DUI charges are the main exceptions. If you finish the terms the judge sets, the case is dismissed and the arrest is treated as if it never happened.
A misdemeanor complaint in Alameda County often feels like the case is already locked onto a conviction track. In California, that is not always how a low-level charge has to end. The judge hearing the case has a tool that does not depend on the prosecutor’s agreement, as long as the current charge is not one the law leaves out.
The rule is in Penal Code section 1001.95. This article explains who can offer that diversion, which current charges are excluded, how long a diverted case can stay open, what the court can require, and what happens if you finish the terms or fall short. If you were charged in Berkeley, the first question is whether section 1001.95 even applies to the offense on the complaint.
Who Can Offer This Diversion?
Section 1001.95(a) gives the decision to a judge of the superior court where the misdemeanor is being prosecuted. That judge may offer diversion at the judge’s discretion, even over the prosecutor’s objection. The statute does not require the prosecutor’s consent, which is what sets it apart from many older diversion programs.
It also does not require the judge to offer diversion in every misdemeanor. The case still has to be a misdemeanor pending in that court, and the current charge still has to fall outside the exclusions in section 1001.95(e). Those two threshold points start the analysis. They do not promise a particular result.
Timing matters, too. Court-initiated diversion is generally treated as a pre-plea option, so it should be raised early, before a plea is entered or the case is set for trial. A conversation with a criminal defense attorney in Berkeley at that stage is about whether the complaint is a qualifying misdemeanor and what terms a judge is likely to set, not about a promise that every Berkeley citation ends in a dismissal. Bring the complaint and the police report to that first conversation. The exclusions have to be checked against the charges actually filed, not against a memory of the stop.
Which Current Charges Are Left Out?
Section 1001.95(e) says diversion under this section is not available for these current charges:
- any offense that would require sex offender registration under Penal Code section 290 if the person were convicted
- any offense involving domestic violence, as defined in Family Code section 6211 or Penal Code section 13700(b)
- a violation of Penal Code section 646.9, the stalking statute
These are bars based on the current charges, not a general character test. A qualifying misdemeanor does not become an excluded offense just because an older, unrelated case appears on your record. The Legislature amended section 1001.95 in 2022 (Statutes 2022, chapter 58, effective June 30, 2022) and kept these three exclusions in place.
What About a Misdemeanor DUI?
DUI is not on the section 1001.95(e) list, and when the law took effect in 2021, some defendants argued that this left misdemeanor DUI eligible. The appellate courts have rejected that argument. An older statute, Vehicle Code section 23640, bars any form of pretrial diversion for a charge under Vehicle Code section 23152 or 23153. The Court of Appeal for the First District, which hears appeals from Alameda County, reached that conclusion in Tan v. Superior Court (2022). Other districts have done the same, and the California Supreme Court has declined to review the issue.
So for a Berkeley DUI, section 1001.95 is generally off the table, and the defense turns to the evidence, the stop, the testing, and negotiation. Readers in that position may find a guide on whether a first-time DUI needs a defense attorney a more useful next step.
How Long Can a Diverted Case Stay Open?
Under section 1001.95(b), a judge can continue a diverted case for up to 24 months. During that time, the judge can order the defendant to follow terms, conditions, or programs that fit the facts of that particular case. There is no single statewide checklist. A Berkeley judge might order counseling, classes, community service, a stay-away order, or other conditions that suit the file.
Penal Code section 1001.96 adds requirements that apply in every case. To earn the dismissal, the defendant has to complete the court-ordered conditions, make any required restitution, and follow any protective order, stay-away order, or firearm restriction the court imposes. An inability to pay restitution because of indigence cannot, by itself, be the reason to deny diversion or to find that a person failed it.
What Happens If You Finish the Terms?
Section 1001.95(c) is the payoff. When the diversion period ends, if you have complied with the terms the court set, the judge must dismiss the case. That dismissal is the result the statute requires for compliance, not a favor the court can hold back after the terms have been met.
Penal Code section 1001.97 then says the arrest is deemed never to have occurred, and you can generally answer questions about your criminal record by saying you were not arrested. There are exceptions. For example, the arrest must still be disclosed on an application for a peace officer position. Keep proof of every completed class or program for the final review date, because the court will look for it.
What If You Fall Short of the Terms?
Section 1001.95(d) addresses a slip. If it appears you are not complying with the diversion terms, the court has to give you notice and hold a hearing on whether the criminal case should resume. If the court finds you did not comply, it can end diversion and restart the criminal proceedings. A missed class or an unpaid term is not an automatic conviction, but it is a reason for that hearing, and it is better to address a problem with the court before the hearing than at it.
When the Better Answer Is Not Diversion
Diversion is a way to avoid a conviction, but it still comes with conditions. Sometimes the stronger path is to show the case should not go forward at all. In one matter on the Silver Law Firm’s results page, a man was charged with resisting arrest after officers responded to a drunk-in-public call and he suffered a fractured skull during the encounter. The defense spent about a year reviewing the officers’ training records, the agency’s use-of-force policies, and the body camera video, then presented evidence that the officers had not followed their own training. The district attorney dismissed the charge.
That case did not involve diversion, but it shows why you should closely review the police report and any video before agreeing to terms. Past results depend on the facts of each case and do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in another matter.
What to Gather in Berkeley
Start with the complaint, the police report, and a written list of the current charges, including any section 290, domestic violence, section 646.9, or Vehicle Code section 23152 count. Those papers decide whether section 1001.95 is on the table. Add anything that shows who you are outside this case, such as proof of work, school, treatment, or community ties, because a judge deciding whether to offer diversion looks at the whole person.
Once you have that charging list, it helps to review the benefits of working with a criminal defense firm, because the exclusions, timing, and 24-month terms must be read against the statute. Compare the file with section 1001.95 before the next court date, and raise diversion before any plea is entered.
Disclaimer
This article provides general information about California law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Diversion eligibility depends on the specific charges, the court, and the facts of each case, so speak with a licensed California attorney about your situation.