
By B. Allen Clardy, Jr., Attorney, The Clardy Law Firm, P.A. · Greenville, South Carolina · Licensed since 1995 | Updated October 2026
Search for an injury lawyer in Greenville and you’ll see plenty of badges, star ratings and big numbers. What you won’t find is a reliable list of who wins in court. That isn’t because the information is hidden; it’s because most injury cases never reach a courtroom, and the ones that do don’t produce a simple scoreboard.
You can still find out a lot about a lawyer’s trial background. This guide explains what results, rankings and court records can and can’t tell you, and which questions get past the marketing.
Bottom line: There’s no accurate “win rate” for injury lawyers, because most claims settle. Instead, ask how many injury cases the lawyer has personally tried to verdict and how recently; check public court dockets; treat badges as a starting point rather than proof, and be wary of anyone who quotes a win percentage or promises an outcome.
Why No One Can Rank Greenville Lawyers by Court Wins
Trials are rare. A Bureau of Justice Statistics study of state courts found that just under 3% of general civil cases, and about 3% of tort cases, were resolved by trial; the rest settled, were dismissed or ended some other way. A “win rate” built on that small slice depends on what is counted. Is a verdict below the last settlement offer a win? What about a case that settled the week before trial, after months of preparation?
South Carolina’s lawyer advertising rule reflects the same concern. Rule 7.1 bars communications likely to create an unjustified expectation about results, and its commentary calls for advertised results to state clearly that similar outcomes are not necessarily available to other clients. A firm that publishes an unexplained win percentage is giving you a number you can’t check.
Reading Verdicts and Settlements in Context
A verdict reflects one jury’s view of one set of facts. A settlement reflects a negotiated compromise, often with confidential terms. Both say something about the cases a lawyer handles, but neither predicts what will happen in yours. A large number may reflect catastrophic injuries and high insurance limits as much as advocacy; a modest one may be an excellent result on difficult facts.
When you review a firm’s published results, look for three things: the type of case, whether the amount came from a verdict or a settlement, and any context about insurance limits or disputed fault. Many results pages, including well-maintained ones, don’t say whether a case was tried, which is exactly why it’s worth asking.
What a Wrongful Death Coverage Fight Shows About Reading Results
One result listed on the firm’s case results page involved a wrongful death claim in which the insurer initially tried to limit coverage to South Carolina’s $25,000 minimum liability limit. The claim ultimately resolved for the $1,000,000 policy limits. The headline figure alone doesn’t tell you the story: the key work was a coverage dispute, not a jury trial. That’s the kind of context worth asking any lawyer about when you look at results. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
What Badges and Ratings Actually Measure
Ratings can help you build a shortlist, but each measures something different, and none is a trial record. (For transparency, the author of this article holds some of these designations.)
| Source | What it generally reflects | What it doesn’t tell you |
| Super Lawyers | Peer nominations, staff research on 12 indicators including verdicts and settlements, and peer evaluation; limited to about 5% of lawyers per state | How many trials the lawyer has handled or how they turned out |
| Martindale-Hubbell (AV rating) | Peer reviews of legal ability and ethical standards | Case outcomes or trial frequency |
| Best Lawyers | Peer review by other lawyers in the same practice area | Trial count or results |
| Avvo rating | An algorithm using experience, disciplinary history, achievements and peer endorsements; client reviews are shown separately | The likely outcome of your case |
| Client reviews | One client’s experience of communication and service | Whether that experience or outcome is typical |
Some national rankings, such as Chambers, focus mainly on business and corporate practice and rarely cover individual plaintiff injury lawyers, so their absence from a Greenville injury lawyer’s profile means little.
Checking the Public Record Yourself
- Search state court dockets. Injury lawsuits in Greenville County are typically filed in the Court of Common Pleas, and the Greenville County Clerk of Court provides access to the public index of civil cases. Searching by attorney or party name can show how many cases a lawyer has filed and how they ended, though not every detail.
- Check federal court. Some injury cases, especially those involving out-of-state trucking companies or manufacturers, are filed in or moved to the U.S. District Court for the District of South Carolina. PACER provides access to those dockets for a small per-page fee.
- Confirm the license and discipline history through the South Carolina Bar’s member directory and the South Carolina Judicial Branch, which publishes disciplinary opinions.
- Be cautious of any firm that quotes a win rate without explaining how it was calculated, or that promises a result.
Questions to Ask at the Consultation
- How many injury cases have you personally tried to a verdict, and when was the most recent? Ask for verdicts specifically, not settlements counted as wins.
- Have you tried a case like mine? A rear-end car claim, a trucking case against a national carrier and a wrongful death case involve different evidence and experts.
- Who will be in the courtroom? The lawyer you meet first may not be the one who tries the case.
- How do you decide whether to recommend a settlement or trial? Listen for how the lawyer weighs evidence, risk, cost and your priorities.
- How will you keep me informed and involved in that decision? The decision to settle belongs to the client.
A lawyer doesn’t need a particular number of trials to be the right fit, but you should understand their relevant experience and how they think about your options. For a broader checklist, see this guide on what makes a good personal injury lawyer.
Does a Good Injury Lawyer Always Go to Trial?
No. The aim is a fair result for your situation, not a trial for its own sake. A settlement can avoid the time, cost and uncertainty of trial, while some disputes, such as a flat denial of fault or a lowball offer on serious injuries, may need a judge or jury to resolve them. What matters is that the lawyer is genuinely prepared to try the case, because insurers tend to factor that readiness into their offers. This explainer on when a car accident dispute goes to trial covers the factors in more detail.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I find a Greenville injury lawyer’s win rate?
Not reliably. Most cases settle, often confidentially, and there is no standard definition of a “win,” so any published win rate should come with an explanation of how it was calculated.
Where can I look up a lawyer’s cases in Greenville County?
Civil injury cases are usually filed in the Greenville County Court of Common Pleas, searchable through the Clerk of Court’s public index; federal cases can be found through PACER.
Do Super Lawyers or Best Lawyers ratings measure trial wins?
Not directly. Both rely heavily on peer review; Super Lawyers counts verdicts and settlements as one of 12 research indicators, but neither publishes a trial record.
Disclaimer
This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Ratings and results described here are not predictions of any outcome, and past results do not guarantee a similar result. If you have an injury claim, consult a licensed South Carolina attorney about your situation.